Gaiad: Chapter 306

Who Names the Good

♎ Libra 26 · Day of Year 306

1In July, eighteen eighty-seven, high In the Upper Engadine's thin air, At Sils Maria, Friedrich Nietzsche, by Month's end, wrote a polemic, dated there;
2The seventeenth, the manuscript was sent Off to Leipzig, Constantin Naumann, who, The year before, the author's money spent, Had printed *Beyond Good and Evil*, too;
3Print this the same, he asked: same type, same press, The paper, that the new go on from old; The title's back: to clarify, no less; Six hundred copies; proofs, in Venice rolled
4With Heinrich Köselitz; and he, in Nice, Got the first copy in November: three Essays, a preface. As a first release, The preface opens: knowers, unknown, we
5Are to ourselves. And under it, the same Question as this calendar's: in what way Did we invent good, evil, and their name; What are they worth? He answered, on the way,
6A friend, a school as well: Paul Rée had laid The moral feelings to their use, the good As what had helped the one who got its aid; Nietzsche would cut it otherwise, and could:
7The first essay, two namings, side by side: Good and bad: nobles named themselves the good, The others plain, low, bad. And then, applied, A second: good and evil, where there stood
8The strong named evil, and the weak named right; He calls it a revolt of slaves; begun, He says, among the Jews. And, in his sight, He gives words' histories: the Latin one1
9For bad means dark; the German in the next: Schuld guilt, Schuld debt: what conscience owes was first A sum once owed; the bad conscience, the vexed Cruelty, with no street, turned in, reversed,
10On one who can't be cruel out the door; He calls the noble a blond beast of prey. The third: ascetic ideals, and what for: Priest, sage, and scientist: each one, a way
11To serve the will to truth, the old will, dressed In later coats; the book ends where it said: We'd rather will the nothing than, at rest, Not will. Keep what is usable; widespread,
12Most of it is: a value has a past; Good was not in the world as stones are; one Said it, of someone, and it spread, held fast, Till speakers had forgot they'd said it; done:
13A method that has stood; and, in its way, This book is a genealogy too: The dead are how the living came; each day Keeps names that came from someone who knew who
14Was called the good, and why, and gave the name. The masters have a point: the nobles who Named themselves good were not a mirror's frame: To name yourself, your house, your line, and do
15It so it sticks, is power, and is worth; It is what founding does, what this faith does, Clearer than council: good, this way on earth, This day, this line. The self-naming that was
16The founding act; the founders' dead, so crowned, Are honored for it. But the good's not theirs Alone: named and unnamed, the line runs round The great, the small, the won, the lost, the heirs.
17This book reads the polemic as a tale Of naming; keep the question that he could Ask, and that lasts: who names it? Answer's trail: The line: the founders, heirs who keep the good,
18And everyone who lived, since each, alive, Knew some good, said it. And the masters' flame Lit it; the line has carried it to thrive; That is the genealogy, its name.
19Six hundred copies left Leipzig; and then, Two months on, some two hundred had been sold; The question outlived the slow sale. Again, Ask where a good came from, its worth; and, old
20And new at once: name your good, as the high Nobles did; keep it, as the line has kept; The naming counted, founders honored, by The will that keeps the good, that never slept.
  1. That etymology, of Latin malus from a Greek word for black, is not accepted. ↩

Cite a stanza as Gaiad 306.1, Gaiad 306.2 and so on (chapter, stanza); each number links to its stanza.